Messages
You may pick up your grade Tuesday November 9 at noon at the reception desk at SUM. Remember your student ID. We are unable to return the essays due to university regulations.
Message from Peder
Remember to write your NAME on the exam ...
Message from Peder:
Please take with you your outline for your exam essay to the seminar meeting on Tuesday. We also need the compendium. We will discuss the essay questions and make strategies for how to answer them. You should by now have made a decision about which of the three questions you would like to answer and made an outline of your essay.
SUM 3011
Desmond McNeill's overheads, 6 october 2004
Two readings which are seeking to influence the public and policy-makers. Both are about water resources.
Reisner p 481
1. Argument: people are finally seeing that water is a limited resource. Irony, and accusation of hypocrisy. Loaded words: 'h eavy-handed bolshevism', 'rugged individualist'….
2. Aswan Dam. Empirical case for comparison, but a one-sided presentation of the case.
3. Argument: long term vs. short term; public vs. private costs and benefits.
No attempt to be neutral: a polemical piece.
---------------------------
McNeill, p. 258
1. What 'water as an economic good' means.
2. There is need for a synthesis, (between economic, social and environmental) but it is unclear what this would mean.
3. What is meant by 'a social good'...
EXAM SUM 3011 2004
Please write an essay of about 8-10 pages answering ONE of following questions. Your answer should be delivered to the reception desk at SUM Wednesday October 20th before 12:00. Good luck.
1. In her article entitled "Thick Resistance", Sherry Ortner makes the statement that "There is life beyond even the most totalizing discourse…" What does she mean to communicate with this statement? Explain the theory of "totalizing discourse" she refers to. What theory does she weigh it against in developing her idea of "thick resistance." Give two examples of discourses which discipline social agency (from a review of literature or from your own experience). Give examples which show that "there is life beyond even the most totalizing discourse."
Ortner, Sherry. 1999. 'Thick Resistance: Death and the Cultural Construction of Agency in Himalaya mountaineering', in S. B...
Message from Desmond MCNeill:
Please bring the compendium to class tomorrow.
Message from Peder Anker
The exam questions will be posted on this website tomorrow during the lecture
Message from Nina Witoszek:
I am in Poland and will only be able to advice students by e-mail. Please send messages and inquiries to: nina.witoszek@sum.uio.no
Message from Jostein Henrik Bakke:
Please read this article before our meeting on Tuesday:
http://www.sudantribune.com/article.php3?id_article=4414
Message from Desmond McNeill:
Please read these articles before the lecture on Wednesday 29 of September:
Marc, Reisner: in M. Reisner: Cadillac Desert: the American West and its Disappearing Water, 1993. "Epilogue: a Civilisation if you can keep it"Penguin Books, pages 477-495.
McNeill Desmond: Natural Resources Forum , 1998. «Water as an Economic Good» pages 253-262..
Partha, Dasgupta: In P. Dasgupta: Human Well-being and the Natural Environment, 2001. Oxford University Press,2001. Chapter 7:"Economic Institutions and the Natural Environment".Pages 107-121.
Taylor Charles: In Philosophy and the Human Sciences, Philosophical Papers 2, 1985. Cambridge University Press. "Interpretation and the Sciences of Man"pages 15-57.
1. Classify the four readings along a scale from 'academic' to 'popular'.
2. Choose which one of the four readings you found most interesting, and say why.
The topic of the colloquium Tuesday 21 will be VOILENCE. What is violence and when is it legitimate?
There will be NO LECTURE Wednesday 22 September. Desmond McNeill is abroad and will lecture as planned September 29 and October 6 .
SEMINAR ESSAY
The essay questions for the module will be posted on this website October 6 (last day of class). The answers are to be short essays of 8-10 pages. The deadline will be Wednesday 20 at noon. Good luck.
Message from Manhar Patel:
These students need a valid student card: Guro Sørnes Trine Staer Ellen Camilla Dahl Skjelsbæk Karoline Ehrenclou Jostein Henrik Bakke
Message from Liv Norderud:
All the students have access to 16 desks with computers and 14 desks without a computer in Sognsveien 70, the 3rd floor. We will in the near future try to provide more desks with computers. There is also a printer in the room for your service. The telephone will give you direct access to the Center’s switchboard in case you need any help.
The room is open for those with a valid student card from 8 in the morning to 8 in the evening. Unfortunately, the door to the building closes at 5 in the evening. If you need to access the room after that, please coordinate with fellow students already inside.
Please feel free to occupy the desks with your books etc. You must bring your own lock for the locker. We stipulate that two students will have to share each desk.
Make this your second home. Bring your coffee mugs and posters!
Everybody must read both articles for the discussion today
Peder
NEW STUDENT REPRESENTATIVE for FIRST YEAR STUDENTS:
Evelyn Manyi
Her e-mail is: maeve2us@yahoo.com
Message from Heidi Smith:
....everyone is invited to meet for a drink after class today at Chateau Neuf. We can take the T-bane together for those who don't know where it is...thank you..